Old coins can tell amazing stories, but cleaning them the wrong way can ruin both their history and value. Before you start scrubbing that dirty penny or dull quarter, it's important to understand what you're working with.
According to Jeff Garrett, former president of the Professional Numismatists Guild, "Cleaning coins can reduce their value by 50% or more. Even if the coin looks better to you after cleaning, most experienced collectors would rather have an uncleaned coin."
Some old coins sitting in a drawer might be worth serious money, while others might just need a gentle wipe to look better in your collection. Think of these coins like old family photos – you wouldn't want to damage them by using harsh chemicals or rough handling. The way you clean an old coin can either keep it safe for years to come or accidentally destroy its worth forever.
Keep in mind that not every dirty coin needs cleaning. Sometimes, the natural aging on coins, called patina, actually protects them and adds to their value. If you're unsure about a coin's worth, it's better to leave it alone until you can talk to a coin expert.
Value Matters When Cleaning
Almost every coin collector faces the temptation to clean their old coins, but it's crucial to understand how cleaning affects value before taking action.
We've seen valuable coins lose up to half their worth through improper cleaning. For ancient coins or rare pieces, oxidation actually adds collector interest, and non-destructive cleaning methods can still damage the coin surface.
When in doubt, we recommend seeking professional appraisal first.
##
Let's explore how to properly clean old coins while protecting their value and historical significance.
We'll walk through the essential do's and don'ts of coin cleaning, including specific steps that'll help preserve these precious pieces of history.
In this guide, we'll cover everything from gentle cleaning solutions to proper handling techniques, plus some final thoughts on maintaining your coins' condition after cleaning.
Things to Do When Cleaning Old Coins
Cleaning old coins requires careful attention to detail and a gentle approach to preserve their value and historical significance. While some collectors advise against cleaning coins altogether, there are situations where careful cleaning is necessary to reveal details or prevent further deterioration. The key is to use appropriate methods that won't damage the coin's surface or patina.
- Evaluate collectible value first – Check the coin's potential worth before cleaning, as cleaning may decrease its value.
- Prepare cleaning workspace – Set up a clean, well-lit area with soft cloth or towel as work surface.
- Mix gentle cleaning solution – Combine distilled white vinegar or lemon juice with salt in proper ratios.
- Handle with care – Use gloves or hold coins by edges to prevent oil transfer from fingers.
- Soak briefly – Immerse coin in solution for no more than 15 minutes.
- Rinse thoroughly – Use distilled water to remove all cleaning solution residue.
- Air dry completely – Allow coin to dry naturally without wiping or rubbing.
- Consider oil treatment – Use olive oil soak for heavily encrusted coins requiring gentler cleaning.
- Document condition – Photograph coin before and after cleaning for reference.
- Store properly – Place cleaned coin in appropriate holder or container once completely dry.
Things to Avoid When Cleaning Old Coins
When preserving antique coins, it's essential to understand that improper cleaning methods can cause irreversible damage and greatly diminish their value.
Many well-intentioned collectors have inadvertently destroyed the natural patina and surface details of their coins through aggressive cleaning techniques, turning potentially valuable pieces into common specimens worth only their metal content.
- Harsh chemicals (bleach, acids, commercial cleaners) – These substances can etch the metal surface and cause permanent discoloration.
- Abrasive materials (steel wool, brushes, baking soda) – Create microscopic scratches that destroy the coin's original finish.
- Polishing or rubbing – Leaves visible marks and removes the natural patina that collectors value.
- Acidic solutions (vinegar, lemon juice) – Cause chemical reactions that can pit or corrode the metal.
- Ultrasonic cleaners – Vibrations can create contact marks and damage delicate surfaces.
- Metal polish products – Strip away surface details and leave artificial shine.
- Hot water – Can cause rapid temperature changes that may stress the metal.
- Extended soaking – Prolonged exposure to any liquid can lead to corrosion or chemical damage.
- Rubber bands or adhesives – Leave residue and can cause chemical reactions with the metal.
- DIY cleaning solutions – Untested combinations of household products can have unpredictable effects.
Steps
Cleaning old coins requires a delicate approach to preserve their value and integrity while removing dirt and oxidation.
The key is using gentle cleaning solutions and avoiding harsh chemicals or abrasive materials that could damage the coin's surface. Following a proper cleaning method helps maintain the coin's original patina while effectively removing unwanted buildup and tarnish.
Step 1: Mix 1 cup of distilled white vinegar or lemon juice with 1 tablespoon of salt
Step 2: Place coins in a shallow plastic container, ensuring they don't touch each other
Step 3: Pour the cleaning solution over the coins
Step 4: Let coins soak for 15 minutes
Step 5: Gently wipe coins with a soft cloth or paper towel
Step 6: Re-soak if oxidation persists
Step 7: Rinse thoroughly with distilled water
Step 8: Air-dry completely on a soft, clean surface
Step 9: For heavily encrusted coins, submerge in olive oil
Step 10: Allow encrusted coins to soak for several months if using olive oil method
Final Thoughts
Maintaining your old coins requires careful consideration of whether cleaning is truly necessary.
If you're uncertain, we recommend consulting with an expert, especially for valuable or collectible coins.
When cleaning's needed, stick to non-destructive methods like soaking in distilled water.
Remember to handle coins with gloves and store them in acid-free holders to preserve their condition and value.
##
Cleaning old coins requires careful consideration and a delicate approach. While it may be tempting to scrub away years of dirt and tarnish, preserving the coin's natural patina and avoiding damage should be the top priority.
The safest approach is often the gentlest one – using non-destructive methods like olive oil soaks for crusted coins or mild vinegar solutions when necessary. Remember that many collectors prefer coins in their original condition, even if slightly dirty, over ones that show signs of cleaning.
If you've discovered old coins that you believe may have value, consider consulting a professional numismatist before attempting any cleaning. For those proceeding with cleaning, always use proper handling techniques, wear gloves, and store coins appropriately afterward.
With patience and the right methods, you can help preserve these pieces of history for future generations to enjoy.
Start your coin cleaning journey by gathering the proper materials and creating a clean workspace. Your coins – and their value – will thank you for taking the time to do it right.
